top of page

Avarice (Withholding) & Separate Self


The passion associated with this orientation is Avarice, more precisely understood as Withholding—a continual reluctance to carry oneself more freely than one feels adequately prepared for. This is not primarily an attachment to material possessions, but a withholding of engagement until the circumstances encountered appear genuinely suited to one’s capacities and understanding. Time, attention, energy, knowledge, judgment, and involvement all come to feel valuable because they contribute to the ability to retain a sufficient grasp on the particular life that must be personally undertaken.


This follows naturally from the Five’s heightened attunement to self-governance. Because no one else can fully inhabit one’s circumstances or encounter them through precisely the same understanding, the responsibility for navigating them appears to rest ultimately with oneself. There consequently arises an enduring concern with whether one is sufficiently equipped for the life one alone must live. Knowledge, insight, competence, and self-understanding become important not merely because they are interesting, but because they promise a greater capacity to meet reality with confidence and mastery.


Lived experience therefore becomes a continual source of information about personal sufficiency. Each circumstance reveals something about how one understands, responds to, and solves the problems presented by life. Through reflecting upon these experiences, perspective, judgment, and capacities are gradually developed through which future situations may be navigated more effectively. From this emerges a sense of control—not primarily the power to shape reality according to one’s will, but the feeling of retaining a handle on the life one must take on. When circumstances extend beyond present understanding or capacities, that handle can seem to loosen, as though life were escaping a personal grasp, beyond the ability to govern it. Withholding then serves to narrow engagement to a scale that remains comprehensible and manageable.


The corresponding specific delusion may be described as Separate Self. This is the implicit perception that one’s lived experience occupies a plane fundamentally inaccessible to others—that one’s perspective, problems, and process of navigation ultimately belong to oneself alone. Others may advise, accompany, or offer support, but they cannot fully enter the particular experience that one must interpret and resolve from within. The self consequently appears as the primary instrument through which life is understood, managed, and mastered.


Together, Separate Self and Withholding reinforce one another. The more life appears to be a uniquely personal responsibility navigated through a private vantage point, the more important it becomes to preserve and develop the faculties through which that responsibility must be carried. Engagement becomes selective, attention is carefully allocated, and involvement is reserved for what appears manageable or capable of strengthening one’s understanding. In this way, Withholding preserves a sense of control by keeping one’s circumstances within the range of one’s cultivated understanding and capacity. Yet this narrowing can also restrict the lived experience through which greater sufficiency and mastery could develop. The effort to retain one’s handle on life risks replacing participation, leaving one increasingly knowledgeable about life while still uncertain of one’s ability to fully engage it.


At its healthiest, this orientation produces independence of thought, careful discernment, intellectual honesty, and a deep commitment to understanding both oneself and reality. It allows a person to cultivate substantial knowledge and capability, then bring them into the world with unusual precision, confidence, and mastery. When exaggerated, however, preserving control becomes an end in itself. Engagement is continually narrowed or deferred because one never feels sufficiently equipped, while the experiences that might have strengthened that sufficiency remain unentered. The attempt to keep life within one’s grasp can then become the very thing that limits one’s ability to fully undertake it.




bottom of page