Hornevian Triads (Triads of Approach)
Named after Karen Horney (the person who conceived the concept), I find these triads describe the approach an Ennearam type conveys in responding to its existential dilemma.
It is worth noting that when these were conceived by Horney, they were not conceived in relation to Enneagram theory. In Horney's model, she noticed three different variations of people that take on a strategy in response to inner conflict: those that tend to move against others (Expansive solutions strategy,), those that move in adjustment to other's opinions and desires (Self-effacing solutions strategy), and those that move away from others (Resignation strategy).
Over time, it's natural to observe connections and try to tie things together, so it was only natural for those familiar with the Enneagram to also want to see how this model would relate to the Enneagram types, and to integrate it with Enneagram theory. Thus, the Hornevian triads were formally adopted into Enneagram theory, and it came to generally be agreed to associate 378 with the stance of moving against others (Expansive solutions, but Assertive/Aggressive triad in Enneagram theory), 126 with the stance of adjusting towards others (Self-effacing solutions, but Compliant triad in Enneagram theory), and 459 with the stance of moving away from others (Resignation, or Withdrawn triad in Enneagram theory).
So, the Hornevian triads have really been a model of how the types orient themselves towards others. However, after spending a decent time engaged in Enneagram theory, it starts to become noticeable how framing it that way doesn't always line up quite so neatly. A type like 6, for example, doesn't always result in "moving towards others" like this framing would suggest—and, truly, each type is an existential orientation of how we approach life as a whole, not specifically about how we approach other people. Often, each orientation, like with type 6, can result in moving away from others, towards them, or against them, more based on context—rather than the existential orientation itself prescribing a fixed interpersonal stance. So, it becomes more meaningful to keep things in the context of how types describe that existential relationship towards existence itself rather than specifically towards people.
For that reason, my proposed reframing of the Hornevian types tries to retain some semblance of the original Horney model, but tries to remain true to the existential themes Enneagram theory attempts to explore and delve into. In the process, it can still provide insight on how people of certain types tend to approach others—but without claiming that they are specifically always moving towards, against or away others. Rather, that their way of approaching of others at any given time is more generally done in relation to their existential orientation. So, type 6 may move away, against, or towards others at any given time, but in this reframing we are saying when they do engage any of these strategies, it is generally done as an expression of them trying to seek alignment (the Compliant approach) with an orientation that they feel promises a sense of security.
Below is a brief summary of each Hornevian triad under this reframing, each describing how an existential dilemma (the one presented by the Primary Triad that a type corresponds to) is approached—not a fixed social behavioral pattern:
-
Compliant types seek resolution through alignment and orientation. (126)
-
Assertive types engage the dilemma through direct action and engagement with reality, i.e. impact. (378)
-
Withdrawn types relocate emphasis inward, pulling attention away from the external field. (459)